Bay Harbor Islands condos had a median sale price of $670,000 in the third quarter of 2026, according to MIAMI Realtors' local market metrics. The average sale price that quarter was $1,014,639. In March 2026 a penthouse at Onda, at 1135 103rd Street, sold for $7.8 million, which the Miami Herald put at about $1,537 a square foot. Both numbers describe the same small town of two islands west of Bal Harbour. Taken together they show a market with two price tiers, and the developers building the upper tier have put a price on the land under both. One of the new eight-story buildings rises where a 1956 condominium stood, and what that building sold for as a whole is a useful guide to what an older waterfront unit holds today.
A median with a long upper tail
The MIAMI Realtors third-quarter 2026 report counted 36 townhouse and condo closings in Bay Harbor Islands, up 44% year over year. The median rose 31.4% and the average rose 40%. When the average sits about $345,000 above the median, a minority of high-priced sales is pulling the average up while most closings stay near the middle. The boutique buildings, with residences priced from the low millions to $10 million and above, sit in that upper tail.
The same report shows how unusual that spread is next door. In Bal Harbour, the Q3 2026 median was $2,087,500 across 29 closings. Bal Harbour's oceanfront towers make for a fairly uniform luxury market. Bay Harbor's median is less than a third of Bal Harbour's, but the town's top sales are now in the same price range.
Supply runs deeper too. At the end of the third quarter, Bay Harbor Islands had 156 active condo and townhouse listings and 15.6 months of supply. That compares with 12.5 months in Bal Harbour and 12.3 months across Miami-Dade County. Bay Harbor's figure was down 27.1% from a year earlier, so the overhang is shrinking. Cash buyers accounted for 25 of the 36 closings in the quarter.
What an older building sells for as a whole
A useful guide to the value inside an older Bay Harbor unit is what developers paid for whole buildings and waterfront sites.
In August 2022, according to the account PPG Development republished, PPG BHT Owner LLC, managed by PPG's Ari Pearl, paid $32 million to buy out the owners of the original Bay Harbor Towers. It was a 30-unit condominium built in 1956 on East Bay Harbor Drive, and it was slated for demolition and redevelopment with L3C Capital Partners. That works out to about $1.07 million per unit. Most of that money paid for waterfront land and the right to build more on it, since the building itself was going to be torn down. The replacement, also called Bay Harbor Towers, is an eight-story building with 44 residences. It topped off on November 18, 2025, and WhatNow reported that at that point it was 75% sold, with the remaining residences priced from $2.6 million and two penthouses from $10 million.
Regency Development Group bought four East Bay Harbor Drive waterfront sites in 2022 for a total of $22.5 million, as The Real Deal reported. The parcels at 9927 and 9955 sold together for $13.5 million, and those at 9781 and 10301 sold for $4.5 million each. On the $4.5 million lot at 9781, Regency planned La Maré's nine-unit Signature Collection. When sales launched in April 2023, The Real Deal reported asking prices of $2.9 million to $6.3 million. The 33-unit Regency Collection at 9927 launched at $1.4 million to $5.8 million. A La Maré Regency penthouse of about 8,000 interior square feet was reported sold for $17 million in February 2025, South Florida Agent Magazine reported. That is roughly $2,125 per interior square foot.
Westdale's affiliate 9291 EBH Ltd. paid $11.25 million in 2022 for a site at 9291–9301 East Bay Harbor Drive. In January 2026, according to Florida YIMBY, it brought a proposal for an eight-story, 33-condo building before the town's Development Review Committee.
An older waterfront unit selling near the $670,000 median is valued partly as an apartment and partly as a share of a lot that a developer has already shown it will buy. The new units show what that land is worth once it holds an eight-story building.
The new buildings, where they stand
As of mid-November 2026, here is where each building stands, based on the most recent dated report for each.
| Building | Address | Residences | Latest reported milestone |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Well | 1177 Kane Concourse | 65 to 66 | TCO in April 2026, 90% sold |
| La Baia South | 9201 East Bay Harbor Drive | 68 | TCO in January 2026 |
| Bay Harbor Towers | 10141 East Bay Harbor Drive | 44 | Topped off November 2025 |
| 9900 West | 9900 West Bay Harbor Drive | 23 | Topped off in late 2025, with an earlier target of summer 2026 |
| Origin Residences by Artefacto | 9760 West Bay Harbor Drive | 27 | 20 of 27 presold by June 2025, late 2026 target |
| La Baia North | 9481 East Bay Harbor Drive | 57 | Topped off April 2026, completion expected 2027 |
| Westdale proposal | 9291–9301 East Bay Harbor Drive | 33 | Before the Development Review Committee, January 2026 |
The Well, built by Terra, has received the most coverage. CoStar reported its April 2026 opening with condo prices starting at $1.2 million and 102,000 square feet of office space in the project. CoStar also noted the building is within walking distance of Bal Harbour Shops and the beaches. Origin had presold 20 of its 27 units by June 2025, with contracts ranging from $1.5 million to $4 million, according to citybiz. In December 2025, citybiz reported that Horizon Group's 9900 West had topped off and was nearly half sold. Continuum's La Baia North topped off on April 25, 2026, according to Florida YIMBY.
Delivery timing is the biggest unknown for a buyer here. When Bay Harbor Towers topped off, PPG's stated target was the third quarter of 2026, and that quarter has ended. 9900 West's December 2025 announcement anticipated delivery in summer 2026. La Baia South received its temporary certificate of occupancy in January 2026, and The Real Deal reported in August 2026 that a court filing said the final certificate was still pending at that time. For a buyer, the practical point is that the dates in a sales presentation are targets. In the 2026 news cycle, the gap between topping off and move-in has run long.
What the two tiers mean for a buyer choosing between them
A buyer comparing an older waterfront unit with a new boutique residence is choosing between two ways of owning the same kind of land. Some of the value in an older unit is the option of a whole-building sale like the 2022 deals, but that sale depends on the other owners and on a developer's interest. A new unit, from roughly $1,500 a square foot at a completed building like Onda to more than $2,000 at a La Maré penthouse, has already captured that value. That buyer is also paying for a new building, larger floor plans and private terraces, and in buildings still under construction is taking on the risk of when they will be finished.
The Q3 2026 data adds a timing point for both groups. With 15.6 months of supply, the deepest of the three markets compared here, buyers have time to compare and negotiate. The median tells a buyer where most of the quarter's 36 closings landed, and the new buildings show where the price records are being set.
Quick answers
Is Bay Harbor Islands priced like Bal Harbour? At the top, close to it. Across the market, no. The Q3 2026 Bay Harbor median of $670,000 compares with $2,087,500 in Bal Harbour. Bay Harbor's top new-construction sales are in the same range as Bal Harbour's.
Which new Bay Harbor buildings have reached occupancy? Onda was completed in 2024. The Well received its temporary certificate of occupancy in April 2026 and La Baia South in January 2026, with La Baia South's final certificate still pending as of the August 2026 report. Bay Harbor Towers, 9900 West, Origin and La Baia North have each passed key construction milestones, with targets reported from 2026 into 2027.
Is more redevelopment coming? The Westdale proposal at 9291–9301 East Bay Harbor Drive was before the town's Development Review Committee in January 2026, so the pattern of the 2022 deals is still playing out.
If you are weighing an older waterfront residence in Bay Harbor Islands against a new boutique building, or deciding when to sell one, Dora Puig and the Luxe Living Realty team can compare recent closings and the status of each building on East and West Bay Harbor Drive with you, one address at a time. Explore our Bal Harbour and Bay Harbor guide, then Let's Connect.